Skip to main content

An interesting discussion on the journal club of CMP: about the discovery of chiral Majorana zero modes in QAHI by K. Wang and S.C. Zhang

After the publication of this paper, about the signature of chiral Majorana zero modes in the quantum anomalous Hall insulator, Prof. Jason Alicea wrote a commentary on Journal Club for Condensed Matter Physics.

However, Prof. Beenakker wrote another commentary to oppose this experiment, in which he cited two theoretical articles showing that the e2/2h does not need the presence of chiral Majorana modes. This argument is actually just recently confirmed by a recent experiment.

It is always fun to read the discussions between physicists. Science evolves through them.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

My Academia Exit - From a Physicist to an RF Engineer

After seeing Ashley Ruba's twitter post about salaries in the academia vs industry, I would like to share my experience of switching career after 4 years of postdocs. When I was young, I used to dream about being a scientist like the professors I met in the class and famous physicists I knew on the books. I was fortunate enough that I was able to get into Duke Physics, where I started my dream and had been a physicist for about 9 years until last September, when I switched to work in the industry at an age of 34. Many facets of the academia convinced me to switch my career. My PhD life at Duke (~ 5 years) My research experience at Duke University was actually a great journey that I really enjoyed doing research and learned the experimentalists' mindset from my advisor Prof. Finkelstein. To be honest, my learning curve of being a low temperature physicist is actually quite long. With my undergraduate degree in electrical engineering, I had minimal knowledge in physics prior to ...
Post a Comment
Read more

What are the benefits of getting a Ph.D.? A perspective from a Ph.D. physicist now working in the chip industry

After working as a postdoc for four years, I recently left academia and enjoy my new life working in the industry. As my current role does not require a Ph.D. degree, I sometimes feel regretful about not starting my industry career earlier. Looking back on my decision of getting a Ph.D. in physics, I used to be passionate about doing scientific research and imagined myself working as a physicist in a research institute like my former employer LLNL. I decided to leave academia because I was tired of the uncertainties in both research itself and personal finance as a postdoc, especially after my son was born.  After watching an inspiring interview with Prof. George A. Constantinides  posted by Shilicon (老石) on YouTube, I feel resonated with one of the sentences by George. He said that getting a Ph.D. is a rare chance that you can have a certain block of time in your life where you can focus on a specific research field and dig deeply into it without worrying too much about other...
Post a Comment
Read more